Which is best: Wells Fargo Active Cash, Citi Double Cash® Card, Capital One Quicksilver?

None of the three dominates: Wells Fargo Active Cash and Citi Double Cash® Card match the best real rate in the same number of everyday categories once rates are valued in real cents per dollar, and all three cost nothing to hold. The right answer depends on where your spending actually lands.

How do you compare these three fairly?

Every category is scored as the printed earn rate multiplied by our conservative value for the currency it pays, giving real cents back per dollar. That stops a large multiplier in a low-value currency from looking better than a smaller one in a high-value currency. Issuer-portal-only rates are excluded from the headline math, and no ranking has any access to which cards pay us a commission.

Three-way comparisons → Wells Fargo Active Cash vs Citi Double Cash® Card vs Capital One Quicksilver

Wells Fargo Active Cash vs Citi Double Cash® Card vs Capital One Quicksilver

All three side by side, every category valued in real cents per dollar — the printed rate times our conservative value for the points it pays, which is the same math the Credit Upside engine runs on every charge. Card data verified 2026-08-21.

Category	Wells Fargo Active Cash	Citi Double Cash® Card	Capital One Quicksilver
Dining	2.0¢/$ (2%)	2.0¢/$ (2%)	1.5¢/$ (1.5%)
Groceries	2.0¢/$ (2%)	2.0¢/$ (2%)	1.5¢/$ (1.5%)
Gas	2.0¢/$ (2%)	2.0¢/$ (2%)	1.5¢/$ (1.5%)
Travel	2.0¢/$ (2%)	2.0¢/$ (2%)	1.5¢/$ (1.5%)
Flights	2.0¢/$ (2%)	2.0¢/$ (2%)	1.5¢/$ (1.5%)
Hotels	2.0¢/$ (2%)	2.0¢/$ (2%)	1.5¢/$ (1.5%)
Streaming	2.0¢/$ (2%)	2.0¢/$ (2%)	1.5¢/$ (1.5%)
Transit	2.0¢/$ (2%)	2.0¢/$ (2%)	1.5¢/$ (1.5%)
Online retail	2.0¢/$ (2%)	2.0¢/$ (2%)	1.5¢/$ (1.5%)
Issuer travel portal portal only	2.0¢/$ (2%)	5.0¢/$ (5%)	1.5¢/$ (1.5%)
Everything else	2.0¢/$ (2%)	2.0¢/$ (2%)	1.5¢/$ (1.5%)
Annual fee	None	None	None
Statement credits (max/yr)	—	—	—
Foreign transaction fee	3%	3%	None
Rewards currency	cash back	cash back	cash back
Signup bonus	10,000 after $500/3mo	—	—
Offer last confirmed	2026-09-14	—	—

No single card runs away with this. Wells Fargo Active Cash and Citi Double Cash® Card match the best real rate in the same number of everyday categories (10 of 10 each), and all three cost nothing to hold — so the answer is whichever one matches your spending, and what its credits and perks are worth to you.

Cents per dollar = printed earn rate × our conservative point value. A big multiplier in a cheap currency loses to a small one in an expensive currency, which is exactly why we never rank on the raw number. The issuer-travel-portal row is shown for reference but excluded from the verdict — it only pays if you book through that issuer's own site, which is a condition, not a category. The same goes for a rate that only pays at one brand (14x at Hilton, 8x on United fares): it is printed under the card's flat rate, labelled, and never counted. Caps, rotating categories and credits you forget to use change the real answer — the app applies all of them to your actual statement.

Prefer them two at a time?

Run your own spending through all three — free

← All three-way comparisons · Head-to-head comparisons · Best-card guides